Part One: History
Yeah, I'm doing this slightly differently than the 8/8 Direct. This is mainly because the speculation and rumors between the September Direct and this one are too significant to split up between the three fighter reveals.
I don't know what happened, but the speculation leading into this Direct got cranked up to 11. Every single week it felt like there were so many more rumors and "leaks" than usual. Just about every leaker, credible or not, seemed to give their own takes, such as Vergeben singling out Incineroar as the Gen 7 Pokemon being represented, as well as stating for sure that he and Ken were locks, but not knowing if there would be any more beyond that. This lined up with the Box Theory, which was taken from the collector's edition box that had every fighter on each side, seemingly only having two slots left for newcomers.
While we know now that all of the above came into fruition, the two biggest leaks before the launch were yet to come. The first happened at the end of September where a screenshot of a battle on Moray Towers was posted, including Ivysaur, Pichu, Pac Man, and the yet-to-be-announced Ken. Many tried to disprove this leak, noting Pichu's ear being cut off on the in-game portrait, as well as Ken's foot slightly clipping through the floor. When recreated in a demo, however, it was found that these were simply just the game's own imperfections.
Quite possibly the most infamous "leak" going into Ultimate happened towards the end of October in which a picture of a seemingly completed Everyone is Here banner was posted by an anonymous person who seemingly worked for an advertising company. Near the finished banner, a version of the banner with no fighters, and what seemed to be set up instructions for a looping display for it was an unseen render of the Grinch for the then-upcoming Grinch movie. This leak would soon become known as the Grinch leak, splitting the community as to who did and didn't buy into it.
Now the Grinch leak had a lot going for it, but also a lot going against it. The leak included seven newcomers: Shadow and Ken as echo fighters, and Banjo, Geno, Chorus Kids, Mach Rider, and Issac (with some also thinking they saw Skull Kid in it as well). This just flat out felt too good to be true. Even outside of all of these being very popular fan picks (which, in its defense, was a commonly recurring theme in the Ultimate fighter reveals), seven new fighters just felt like too much considering Sakurai's statement not to expect "too many new fighters." Mix that with the fact that many of the most credible leakers were confused about the lack of Incineroar, and there was a lot going against the leak's validity.
On the other side of things, evidence within the picture revealed the name of someone whose LinkedIn revealed they had ties to a French publishing company, suggesting this was indeed real marketing material. Other evidence was found through official means, such as some miscolored pixels that were found on the banner after Isabelle was added, which lined up with the placement of Issac in the leaked version. Beyond that, a trailer posted a few days later showed an unrevealed item that bore resemblance to an item found in the Golden Sun series, seemingly giving even more validity to the leak.
Things would soon come to a head, however, as at the end of the month, the final Smash Direct before the launch of Ultimate was announced, amping the community up even more, and increasing the debates as to what was real and what was not for just a few more days.
Before this, however, Vergeben posted one last leak. It was said that the Grinch Leak was fake, Ken and Incineroar were the last two in the base roster, and that Issac would be an assist trophy instead of a fighter.
And then came the Direct...
Part Two: My History
Here's where my bias starts. Going into Ultimate, there were four main fighters I wanted in the game. Shovel Knight was the first fighter I ever wanted in Smash, and he would become an assist trophy. I wanted an ARMS rep, and my mind immediately went to Spring Man, who would soon be revealed as an assist trophy as well. Of course, I would get my wish there later, but that's for another post. Inkling was up there, but I figured they were a lock anyway, so I didn't think too much into it. My top pick, however, above all others was Incineroar. I'll get to the specifics as to why later, but this is pretty crucial information as to my thoughts during this wave of leaks.
Throughout this entire cycle, I was trying to keep my expectations as low as possible as to whether or not Incineroar would get in. Honestly, I never really expected it to happen. Decidueye seemed to be the more popular starter in Gen 7, especially after his inclusion in Pokken, and nobody was really predicting Incineroar. Heck, quite frankly I, myself, would have been totally fine with Decidueye, though I would have much rather gotten the other. Right around when Smash was first revealed for Switch though, I suddenly thought about how much fun Incineroar could be, between all of the grappler/wrestler type attacks that he could use. Heck, I even thought about how his reveal trailer might play out. I figured it would start with two fighters fighting in the boxing ring, one of which getting defeated, and then Incineroar would come in out of nowhere and start wailing on them (I've had a tendency to get the general concepts of reveal trailers correct, only missing a few details. In this case, I didn't factor in that it could double as another character's reveal, with said character being the one fighting Little Mac at the start).
Of course, there was plenty of bias from my end. Sun and Moon were the first games I was really *there* for during the reveal cycle, and when the starters were revealed, I immediately decided on Litten. Even though I was a bit disappointed with Incineroar when the final evolutions of the starters were leaked, he quickly grew on me as I saw gameplay and especially once I played the game for myself. By the time I finished the game, he was easily my favorite Pokemon.
So yeah, as one would expect, I definitely didn't want to get my expectations up too high. Things would change as I started seeing more leaks though, especially when I first heard Vergeben's statement that there would indeed be a Gen 7 Pokemon and that it would not be Decidueye, Lycanrok, or Mimikyu. Of course, I was thinking "ok if this is real, wouldn't that suggest Incineroar?" The only thing is I tried not to put too much trust into that leak so I could avoid disappointment. As the months went on, however, and Incineroar began to become a more prominent candidate for the game (heck, Vergeben even eventually stated it was, in fact, Incineroar), I started to believe.
Then came the Grinch leak.
I'll be honest, I was fooled by it. I don't know if it was everyone else acting like it was real or what, but I believed it 100% (well, maybe a tiny bit less than that because I never wanted to go all-in on believing a leak, but still). Something I forgot to mention earlier that I feel is necessary to mention now is that Charizard was my main in Smash 4 and once I found out he was part of Pokemon Trainer again, I knew I probably needed to find a new main. The only issue is I wasn't really feeling anyone on the roster. I figured that if anything, I'd fall back on Inkling going into Ultimate, but I was still holding out a little hope for Incineroar since I knew I would likely main him if he got in. The Grinch leak completely killed that hope for Incineroar, but it at least contained a few characters I would have been interested in, even if I didn't main them. Banjo and Geno were both characters I wanted specifically because I knew how big their fanbases were for their individual inclusions, so they were both in my mind. Chorus Kids were characters I was sad to find out were possibly cut from Smash 4, so I was very excited about their inclusions as well. Finally, even though I didn't really know Mach Rider before then, I had always liked the idea of an Excitebiker as the new retro rep for a game, so Mach Rider filled that hole for me.
Ultimately, however, I was saddened by the fact that Incineroar wasn't there, and was trying to make myself feel a bit better about it. One video I saw talking about leakers being confused about Incineroar being missing was suggesting that maybe he was just moved to DLC so they could get Banjo into the base roster, justified by Banjo trademarks recently being made, suggesting that he might have been decided on earlier that year. This was the conclusion I decided to follow and it helped me not feel like all hope was completely lost, at least outside of the base roster.
Of course, though, the Direct then came...
Part 3: Ken and Incineroar
This was another Direct I had to watch in bits between classes throughout the school day. Honestly, if I could change any one thing about my viewing experience with this Direct is that I would have rather been at home instead of school because I definitely suffered for it. Honestly the fact I didn't get to react properly is probably the reason I'm still shaken over it (in a good way).
So like the previous one, it started right at the end of class for me. I went in expecting the Grinch leak fighters to be revealed, so when the trailer started and Ken was shown, I was like "yep, there we go. The leak is definitely real." For reference, I totally forgot Ken was even mentioned in Vergeben's leak, so he seemed to confirm the Grinch leak in my mind. I will admit though, there was a split second at the beginning of the reveal where I thought it was Incineroar, since the boxing ring setting lined up pretty well with my concept of an Incineroar reveal trailer.
So I was completely clueless. By the end of the gameplay section of Ken's half of the trailer, I was walking out fo my class over to the break time hangout spot my friends and I had. I had to pause, but before I did, it zoomed into the eyes in the doorway, and my first thought was Shadow. My line of thinking was that they probably jsut wanted to do a dedicated echo fighter reveal trailer, just to add a bit more flair rather than Chrom's and Dark Samus's barebones reveal trailers.
Then came the segment after Little Mac got thrown into the screen. That little first person segment of Incineroar running to the ring. At first I was like "yup, it's Shadow because he's running I guess," but then the flames started showing up around the edges of the screen and I was like "wait, fire isn't a Shadow thing is it?" That was when I started to get suspicious, only amplified by the shadowy, firey figure landing in the ring with that immediately recognizable flame belt. EVEN THEN I was trying as hard as I possibly could not to believe that it was indeed Incineroar. My mind was a mix of trying not to believe it was him (with the constant repetition of "nowaynowaynowaynoway..."), as well as me trying to verify that it was indeed Incineroar's belt, all while multiple feelings of hype, disbelief, etc. started to rise up in my stomach.
Aaaaaannnnndddd then he roared, his face was revealed, and the splash screen happened.
I yelled.
You know when you watch a Smash reveal and you're so hyped you miss/don't even process the gameplay segment? Yeah, that was me. There are exactly five times so far that I screamed at a Smash reveal (and the same number for when I was shaking during/after it). Inkling, Incineroar, and a few that we will get to within the next few entries.
Legitimately I was so hyped and not even thinking that on accident, I immediately spoiled my friend who was nearby but planning on watching the direct later that day.
Now I know most people were likely disappointed in this, especially since it deconfirmed the Grinch leak, and the second they said Incineroar was the last newcomer, I immediately thought "uh oh..." just because I knew that would likely increase any disappointment people had. Nevertheless, I was still hyped out of my mind, and nobody can take that from me.
As for how they play, I really love both of them. Incineroar, of course, is my main, as my continued rambling about him has likely implied, but who I didn't expect to play as much as I do was Ken. Honestly, I kinda contribute some of that to the fact he was announced alongside my top pick, but yeah, I unlocked Ken in the game and decided to try him out just because he had the trailer connection, and I ended up having a lot of fun with him. Before this point, I had never played a Street Fighter game (or really any traditional fighter, for that matter), but because of Smash and the fact that I really enjoyed playing Ken, I would go on and end up buying multiple games in the series over the next few months. That's something else I really love about Smash. You may vaguely know about a series but never really give it a shot, but then you find a character from said series in Smash and that can be the tipping point. It's amazing to me just how awesome Smash is at being able to introduce people to new series that may not have reached them beforehand. Smash is inherently an advertisement, but in a way where you don't really care because everything is so interesting and true to their sources. I'll likely touch on this a bit more throughout some upcoming entries in this series, but yeah, it's just amazing to me that because a character I love got announced alongside a character I only moderately knew, I was fully introduced to a new series that I may not have ever thought to try out otherwise.
Now, the funny thing about these reveals is that both fighters had been very heavily speculated/rumored/leaked (especially in Ken's case), so to most, neither of these were that big of a surprise. However, shortly after announcing the first Fighters Pass, we are given a trailer for a bonus fighter that absolutely nobody seriously saw coming...
Part 4: Piranha Plant
What do I even say about this one?
As far as leaks beforehand, there were almost none for this. The only one found that maybe was credible was discovered after this Direct had ended, and it was just a 4chan post from late September 2018 saying Ken, Incineroar and a potted Piranha Plant were the last newcomers. Credible or not, I think I speak for most when I say practically nobody would have taken this seriously. Heck, I think this reveal probably caused people to be more believing of absurd-sounding leaks. I distinctly remember not long after this reveal, a YouTuber covered a leak for the Fighters Pass in which they claimed the 5th Fighter would be a GameCube controller (which honestly, why not at this point?).
Anyway, as with Ken and Incineroar, this reveal fell victim to the combination of the timing of this Direct and my lack of control. This one got hit even harder since it happened during class. I remember shortly after the Ken/Incineroar reveal, I had to get to my next class, and all throughout it I had my laptop open to the Direct, but my mobile hotspot and school wifi were being trash that day so the stream kept buffering and I constantly had to refresh. Eventually, I see the moveset information segment for a Piranha Plant and I'm just sitting there really confused and thinking I missed something.
At first, I was worried that people were going to be pissed that this got in over (insert character here), but I was (and still kinda am) surprised to see that the reception was more positive than anything. I think the pick was just so out there that most people were more willing to accept it or something like that. At the very least, that would explain the contrasting receptions between this and some of the DLC characters (though that could also probably be contributed to the constantly changing community).
As for playing it in-game, this is another character that really clicked with me. Plant is definitely not one of my mains by any means, but I really like its moveset and find it fun to casually play as every now and then.
Conclusion
So yeah, I went into this Direct expecting confirmation of the Grinch leak, but I got way more out of it than that. The leak got deconfirmed in what was, for me at least, the best way possible with my first top pick getting into the game. As for the other reveals, even though they may not have been as exciting for me at the time, both would become some of my favorites to play in the game, with one of them properly introducing me to a new series altogether.
Also just some little notes about this series and its future: so this entry was started at the end of September and I just kinda kept forgetting to come back to it. There may be some inaccuracies between now and then since we have gotten an additional 3 character reveals, and I tried to update everything I could, so just keep that in mind. As for the future of the series, I'm not sure how consistently I'm going to be doing this but I do plan on covering both Fighter Passes (and beyond in the event that we somehow end up with even more DLC). It will likely continue the formula of each post focusing on fighters per event, so characters like Joker, Terry, Steve, etc. will have individual posts, while a Hero/Banjo situation will be relegated to a single post. I'm not entirely sure exactly when I will have the Joker post ready, but I will be sure to get to it as soon as I can.
Until next time...






















